When you design and implement a home security plan, it’s wise to investigate some legal issues that necessarily arise. Laws concerning privacy, gun ownership, security company responses and other issues can become a problem if certain points are not considered up front.

The Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution states (in part):

‘The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated…’

Clearly that’s not a principle that criminals who break into your home are respecting. But even before things get to that stage, it’s important for YOU to respect it. You may inadvertently violate it if you’re not careful. When placing surveillance cameras inside or outside the home, for example, it’s possible to accidentally go too far.

The amendment was intended to protect citizens against government intrusion into privacy. But it has often been more widely interpreted over the years to grant a general right to privacy for anyone against anyone else. You can’t, for example, spy on your neighbor.

If you place a video camera outside that has too wide a sweep, and it happens to peer into your neighbor’s home window by mistake, you need to adjust it. Even inside the home can raise an issue. If you have a camera and audio monitoring system to watch the baby, no one will think anything of it. That’s just being a responsible parent. But place a similar system in a teen’s room without their consent and you’re moving into a legally gray area, especially if you share custody with a divorced spouse.

Gun ownership and use is another complex area of the law. Even though the Second Amendment recognizes the right of gun ownership, it has been subjected to numerous laws defining or restricting it. Most states and municipalities have laws that either outright disallow ownership or at least modify how that right can be exercised. In many cases, those laws are not fully consistent with one another.

As such, it’s wise for someone who is considering buying a firearm for home or personal protection to investigate the local and state regulations on the subject. Some may resent the need to do so, but forewarned is forearmed, as the saying goes. Find out what the law says about the need for registration. Almost all areas require at least this, owing to Federal rules.

Go a step beyond that and investigate what local and state ordinances require or allow in the event you have to discharge the weapon. Even if you don’t actually shoot someone, simply pointing it at someone in the home can raise a legal challenge if the intruder goes to court.

Everyone can agree that the patchwork of sometimes contradictory laws on the subject isn’t helpful. Nevertheless, it’s in your best interest to find out what the law is in your area and how it’s likely to be enforced or interpreted.

Do some research on any home security company you hire to monitor your system and respond to an alarm. Find out what licensing they are required to have versus what they do have. Ask about the real-life experience of the guards, how they would respond to certain realistic and somewhat likely scenarios and more. Don’t assume that the responsibility for following the law rests solely with the company you hire.

You can’t resolve all the inconsistencies in the regulations. But you can protect yourself by understanding what the law in your area says.

Trackback URI | Comments RSS